• devuan-packages
  • base-files
  • Issues
  • #21

Closed
Open
Opened 2016-05-21T11:19Z by Pawe\xc5\x82 Cholewi\xc5\x84ski @positive

typo when reboot and poweroff

I use Polish locale. When I reboot I see typo:

reboot

When I poweroff I see typo:

typo_poweroff

Please solve the reCAPTCHA

We want to be sure it is you, please confirm you are not a robot.

  • Pawe\xc5\x82 Cholewi\xc5\x84ski @positive Title changed from typo on reboot to typo when reboot and poweroff · 2016-05-21T08:23Z

    Title changed from typo on reboot to typo when reboot and poweroff

  • Urban Wallasch
    Urban Wallasch @Irrwahn · 2016-05-22T03:43Z

    To me that glitch looks less like a typo, but rather like one message printed on top of another.

  • Pawe\xc5\x82 Cholewi\xc5\x84ski
    Pawe\xc5\x82 Cholewi\xc5\x84ski @positive · 2016-05-22T09:05Z

    You are right. reboot and poweroff are symbolic link to halt. halt is using shutdown. According to Debian Wheezy it should look that:

    root@devuan-jessie:~#poweroff;
    
    Broadcast message from root@devuan-jessie (tty1) (Sat May 21 10:20:39 2016):
    
    The system is going down for system halt NOW!
    ..

    I assume that\is somewhere missing.

  • Urban Wallasch
    Urban Wallasch @Irrwahn · 2016-05-22T09:26Z

    FWIW: I just tried to reproduce it with a proper Devuan Ascii(sic!) VM and one of the unofficial Jessie beta1 live CDs. In both cases it looked like your Wheezy example, i.e. an empty line printed between "Broadcast ..." and "The system ...". I wonder, if your original observation might have been caused be something peculiar to your system?

    Edited by Urban Wallasch 2016-05-22T09:29Z
  • Pawe\xc5\x82 Cholewi\xc5\x84ski @positive Made the issue confidential · 2016-05-22T19:37Z

    Made the issue confidential

  • Pawe\xc5\x82 Cholewi\xc5\x84ski
    Pawe\xc5\x82 Cholewi\xc5\x84ski @positive · 2016-05-22T19:40Z

    @Irrwahn what is Your hostname - 'devuan'? If yes change it to 'devuan-jessie' in /etc/hosts and /etc/hostname to reproduce issue. If I change hostname to 'devuan' empty line is printed.

    Edited by Pawe\xc5\x82 Cholewi\xc5\x84ski 2016-05-22T19:41Z
  • Pawe\xc5\x82 Cholewi\xc5\x84ski @positive Made the issue visible · 2016-05-22T21:13Z

    Made the issue visible

  • Jaromil
    Jaromil @jaromil · 2016-05-23T09:05Z

    I haven't reproduced anything yet, but sounds like surprisingly connected to debian-installer#53

  • Urban Wallasch
    Urban Wallasch @Irrwahn · 2016-05-23T10:18Z

    Pawe\xc5\x82: Using a hostname containing a hyphen I was indeed able to reproduce it on an Ascii VM (have not tried on Jessie, though). BTW:/etc/hostsdoes not seem to play a role here, but I already expected that. With "devuanjessie" as a hostname it worked fine. Just for fun I changed it to "devuan.jessie" (period instead of hyphen) and the problem reappeared.

    But it gets even weirder: Next, I changed it to "devuan1jessie" and the original problem was there; the same happened for "devuanjessie1"!

    Apparently something that parses /etc/hostname chokes on anything in/etc/hostnamethat is not a lower case letter.

    Jaromil : I agree it looks incredibly related. However, I tried to reproduce it (by invoking update-grub between reboots), but failed to succeed.

    Clearly something fishy is going on here, but more investigation is needed to isolate the cause of this glitch. Until then the only workaround seems to be to only use lower case ASCII characters for the hostname, or just live with the glitch. Not exactly ideal.

    EDIT: For the record, I confirmed my findings using a freshly installed Jessie beta1 VM.

    Edited by Urban Wallasch 2016-05-23T12:12Z
  • Evilham
    Evilham @evilham · 2017-10-31T18:28Z

    Seems to work fine now. May have been an issue with an early version, please reopen if it persists in ascii.

    # halt
    
    Broadcast message from root@ascii-test (pts/0) (Tue Oct 31 18:26:30 2017):
    The system is going down for system halt NOW!
  • Evilham @evilham closed · 2017-10-31T18:28Z

    closed